Can free tools fully replace Ahrefs or Semrush?
For your own site's performance, largely yes: Search Console, Keyword Planner, and Screaming Frog cover monitoring, demand research, and technical auditing. What you lose is competitive intelligence, since free tools cannot show a competitor's keywords, backlinks, or traffic at any useful depth. Most teams pay for a commercial platform precisely when competitor research becomes a regular part of the workflow.
What should a new site set up first?
Google Search Console on day one, because its data only starts accumulating after verification and cannot be backfilled. Then run a Screaming Frog crawl to catch technical problems while the site is small, and check your key templates in PageSpeed Insights. Keyword Planner and Clarity earn their place once there is content to plan and traffic to observe.
Why is Ahrefs Webmaster Tools not on this list?
It is a strong free option for your own verified sites, covering site audit and limited backlink data, and pairs well with everything here. We kept the list to picks that are free without caveats across their core use; AWT is best understood as a free on-ramp to a paid platform, and it is worth installing alongside these tools.